RUGBY league is in the grip paralysis by analysis and no one seems willing or able to sort out the mess.
The video referee system is grossly overused, the referees are confused, the match review committee is clueless and the patients _ as in the coaches and players _ are running the asylum.
Last Saturday night, Bulldogs players argued successfully with referee Gerard Sutton after a Josh Reynolds kick rebounded off Sutton’s legs. The sad part was either they knew more about the rules better or Sutton was so terrified to get something wrong he forgot a basic rule of the game.
Either way it wasn’t a good look.
Then the match review committee inexplicably cleared Bulldogs backrower Josh Jackson of a chicken-wing tackle on Manly’s Josh Starling when the entire rugby league community, apart from those with one blue and one white eye, thought it was a chicken wing.
Sea Eagles captain Jamie Lyon talks to referee Gerard Sutton during the NRL 2nd semi.
Sea Eagles captain Jamie Lyon talks to referee Gerard Sutton during the NRL 2nd semi.
So the bloke who came up with an ugly chicken-wing tackle served no time and the bloke who reacted with a harmless punch copped 10 minutes in the sin bin. It’s insane.
We’re also stopping the game every time a player goes down injured. The video referee checks he hasn’t been injured illegally, the trainer checks him out, the referee stands there like a stuffed toy and the other 25 players on the field take a little breather.
Here’s a tip, refs, unless the player is seriously hurt and the trainer is calling for help, get on with the game. Give the ball to one of the “injured” player’s teammates and get him to play the ball 10 metres away. It’s the way we always did it.
The only way for the game to get out of the rut it’s in is through leadership. Unfortunately, leadership in the NRL is as rare as a lucky break for the Cowboys in the finals.
Todd Greenberg
Todd Greenberg
Former CEO David Gallop was criticised for being reactive rather than proactive but he was a decisive forward thinker compared to the current lot at HQ.
British-born American businessman Harold S Geneen was a clever bloke who had two things to say about leadership: “Leadership cannot really be taught. It can only be learned” and “Management is doing things right; leadership is doing the right things”.
We’re getting an lot of management and little leadership out of the offices of Dave Smith and Todd Greenberg.
Greenberg’s response to the scourge of wrestling in the NRL was to say only the coaches could stop it. So why are we paying you, Todd? Weren’t you hailed as some sort of messiah when you took the NRL job last year? You’re the “head of football”; start heading it.
You can cure the wrestle; you can stop the video referees taking 23 looks at every contentious incident in every game; you can stop the constant rule changes.
All you have to do is show a little leadership.