1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Alternate Eagles - Round 6 - Match up Stats

Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by fLIP, Apr 15, 2005.

  1. fLIP

    fLIP UFO Hunter

    6,779
    351
    Brisbane
    Ratings:
    +790 / 15
    Alternate Eagles, Game Matchup:

    All positions have stats 'Average' appart from Tries and Points.


    MANLY VS CANBERRA

    Fullback:


    Brett Stuart v Clinton Shifcofske

    Tries: Shifcofske 4 - 2
    Points: Shifcofske 62 - 8
    Tackles: Stuart 5 - 3.5
    Offloads: Shifcofske 2.8 - 0.5
    Kicks: Shifcofske 2 - 0.3
    Try Assists: Shifcofske .8 - 0
    Line Breaks: Shifcofske 1.5 - 0.5
    Hitups: Shifcofske 19.8 - 9.3
    Metres Gained: Shifcofske 200 - 79.5
    DH Runs: Shifcofske 3.3 - 1.8
    Errors: Shifcofske 1.8 - 2.3
    Mistackles: Stuart 1 - 1.3

    Overall:
    Clinton Shifcofske - 10
    Brett Stuart - 2


    Wings:


    Scott Donald v Phillip Graham

    Tries: Tied 2 - 2
    Points: Tied 8 - 8
    Tackles: Graham 8.8 - 4
    Offloads: Graham 0.8 - 0
    Kicks: Graham 0.3 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Graham 0.5 - 0
    Hitups: Graham 7.8 - 5.5
    Metres Gained: Graham 63 - 56.8
    DH Runs: Graham 2.5 - 2.3
    Errors: Graham 0.5 - 0.8
    Mistackles: Donald 0.5 - 1.5

    Overall:
    Phillip Graham - 9.5
    Scott Donald - 2.5


    Chris Hicks v David Howell

    Tries: Howell 1 - 0
    Points: Howell 4 - 0
    Tackles: Hicks 6 - 4.5
    Offloads: Tied 0 - 0
    Kicks: Howell 0.3 - 0
    Try Assists: Howell 0.3 - 0
    Line Breaks: Howell 0.5 - 0
    Hitups: Hicks 10 - 8
    Metres Gained: Howell 74.3 - 50
    DH Runs: Hicks 6 - 2.3
    Errors: Hicks 1 - 1.3
    Mistackles: Howell 0.8 - 2

    Overall:
    David Howell - 7.5
    Chris Hicks - 4.5


    Centres:

    Steve Matai v Craig Frawley

    Tries: Frawley 1 - 0
    Points: Frawley 4 - 0
    Tackles: Matai 17.5 - 7.3
    Offloads: Frawley 1.7 - 0
    Kicks: Frawley 0.3 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Tied 0 - 0
    Hitups: Matai 12.5 - 6.7
    Metres Gained: Matai 83 - 52
    DH Runs: Matai 5 - 1.3
    Errors: Matai 0 - 0.7
    Mistackles: Frawley 0.7 - 4

    Overall:
    Craig Frawley - 6
    Steve Matai - 6


    Paul Stephenson v Adam Mogg


    Tries: Mogg 1 - 0
    Points: Mogg 4 - 0
    Tackles: Mogg 15.8 - 8.8
    Offloads: Mogg 0.8 - 0
    Kicks: Tied 0 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Mogg 0.5 - 0
    Hitups: Stephenson 15 - 13
    Metres Gained: Mogg 118 - 87.3
    DH Runs: Stephenson 7.3 - 3.5
    Errors: Stephenson 0.8 - 1.3
    Mistackles: Mogg 0.8 - 2.3

    Overall:
    Adam Mogg - 8
    Paul Stephenson - 4


    5/8th:


    Michael Witt - Jason Smith

    Tries: Smith 4 - 0
    Points: Smith 16 - 0
    Tackles: Witt 19.3 - 17.5
    Offloads: Smith 1.8 - 1.5
    Kicks: Smith 8.3 - 6.8
    Try Assists: Smith 0.5 - 0.3
    Line Breaks: Smith 0.8 - 0.3
    Hitups: Witt 5.3 - 3.3
    Metres Gained: Witt 36.5 - 22.5
    DH Runs: Smith 0.8 - 0.3
    Errors: Witt 1.3 - 2.3
    Mistackles: Witt 2 - 2.3

    Overall:
    Jason Smith - 7
    Michael Witt - 5


    Halfback:


    Michael Monaghan v Lincoln Withers

    Tries: Tied 3 - 3
    Points: Monaghan 13 - 12
    Tackles: Withers 20.5 - 17
    Offloads: Monaghan 1.3 - 0.5
    Kicks: Monaghan 9.3 - 4.5
    Try Assists: Monaghan 1 - 0.3
    Line Breaks: Withers 1.8 - 0.8
    Hitups: Tied 6.5 - 6.5
    Metres Gained: Withers 78.8 - 36.3
    DH Runs: Withers 0.8 - 0
    Errors: Withers 0.5 - 3.5
    Mistackles: Monaghan 2 - 4.8

    Overall:
    Michael Monaghan - 6
    Lincoln Withers - 6


    Hooker:


    Chad Randal v Simon Woolford

    Tries: Randall 1 - 0
    Points: Randall 4 - 0
    Tackles: Randall 21 - 17.5
    Offloads: Woolford 0.8 - 0
    Kicks: Woolford 3.3 - 0.3
    Try Assists: Woolford 0.5 - 0
    Line Breaks: Randal 0.3 - 0
    Hitups: Woolford 5.8 - 3.7
    Metres Gained: Woolford 54.5 - 15.3
    DH Runs: Woolford 3.8 - 2.7
    Errors: Tied 0.3 - 0.3
    Mistackles: Woolford 2.3 - 2.7

    Overall:
    Simon Woolford - 7.5
    Chad Randal - 4.5


    Second Row:


    Steve Menzies v Matt Adamson

    Tries: Menzies 2 - 1
    Points: Menzies 8 - 4
    Tackles: Menzies 26.5 - 13.3
    Offloads: Menzies 1.8 - 1.3
    Kicks: Menzies 0.3 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0.3 - 0.3
    Line Breaks: Adamson 0.3 - 0
    Hitups: Adamson 9 - 8.8
    Metres Gained: Adamson 83.3 - 66
    DH Runs: Menzies 1 - 0
    Errors: Adamson 0 - 1.5
    Mistackles: Adamson 0.5 - 2

    Overall:
    Steve Menzies 6.5
    Matt Adamson 5.5


    Anthony Watmough v Kris Kahler

    Tries: Watmough 3 - 1
    Points: Warmough 12 - 4
    Tackles: Kahler 27.5 - 23
    Offloads: Kahler 1.5 - 1.3
    Kicks: Tied 0 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Tied 0.3 - 0.3
    Hitups: Kahler 17 - 14.3
    Metres Gained: Watmough 121 - 116.5
    DH Runs: Watmough 1.5 - 0.3
    Errors: Kahler - 1 - 1.3
    Mistackles: Kahler 2.3 - 2.8

    Overall:
    Kris Kahler - 6.5
    Anthony Watmough - 5.5


    Front Row:


    Brent Kite v Tyran Smith

    Tries: Kite 1 - 0
    Points: Kite 4 - 0
    Tackles: Kite 22.3
    Offloads: Smith 2 - 1.3
    Kicks: Tied 0 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Kite 0.3 - 0
    Hitups: Kite 14.8 - 14
    Metres Gained: Smith 121 - 110.8
    DH Runs: Tied 0 - 0
    Errors: Smith 0 - 1.3
    Mistackles: Smith 2 - 3

    Overall:
    Brent Kite - 6.5
    Tyran Smith - 5.5


    Daniel Heckenberg v Troy Thompson

    Tries: Heckenberg 1 - 0
    Points: Heckenberg 4 - 0
    Tackles: Thompson 22 - 20
    Offloads: Thompson 1 - 0.3
    Kicks: Tied 0 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Heckenberg 0.3 - 0
    Hitups: Thompson 16 - 12.8
    Metres Gained: Thompson 108.3 - 102
    DH Runs: Heckenberg 0.3 - 0
    Errors: Thompson 0.3 - 0.5
    Mistackles: Heckenberg 1 - 1.5

    Overall:
    Daniel Heckenberg - 6
    Troy Thompson - 6


    Lock Forward:


    Ben Kennedy v Jason Croker

    Tries: Croker 1 - 0
    Points: Croker 4 - 0
    Tackles: Kennedy 25.8 - 21.3
    Offloads: Croker 2.3 - 1.3
    Kicks: Croker 0.7 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0.3 - 0.3
    Line Breaks: Croker 0.7 - 0
    Hitups: Kennedy 12.3 - 10.7
    Metres Gained: Kennedy 104 - 81.3
    DH Runs: Tied 0.3 - 0.3
    Errors: Kennedy 1 - 1.3
    Mistackles: Kennedy 1 - 1.7

    Overall:
    Jason Croker - 6
    Ben Kennedy - 6


    Bench:


    Luke Williamson v Michael Weyman

    Tries: Tied 0 - 0
    Points: Tied 0 - 0
    Tackles: Williamson 21.5 - 7.5
    Offloads: Willaimson 0.5 - 0
    Kicks: Williamson 0.8 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Tied 0 - 0
    Hitups: Weyman 9.3 - 4.5
    Metres Gained: Weyman 86 - 28
    DH Runs: Williamson 0.5 - 0
    Errors: Williamson 0 - 0.3
    Mistackles: Williamson 0.8 - 1.3

    Overall:
    Luke Williamson - 8
    Michael Weyman - 4


    Shayne Dunley v Matthew Gafa

    Tries: Dunley 2 - 1
    Points: Dunley 8 - 4
    Tackles: Dunley 17.3 - 8
    Offloads: Gafa 0.3 - 0
    Kicks: Dunley 0.3 - 0
    Try Assists: Dunley 0.3 - 0
    Line Breaks: Dunley 0.5 - 0
    Hitups: Gafa 6.8 - 6
    Metres Gained: Dunley 58.5 - 56.5
    DH Runs: Dunley 5.3 - 2
    Errors: Gafa 0.5 - 0.8
    Mistackles: Gafa 0.8 - 2

    Overall:
    Shayne Dunnley - 8
    Matthew Gafa - 4


    Kylie Leului v Ian Hindmarsh

    Tries: Tied 0 - 0
    Points: Tied 0 - 0
    Tackles: Hindmarsh 15 - 12.5
    Offloads: Tied 0 - 0
    Kicks: Tied 0 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Tied 0 - 0
    Hitups: Tied 7 - 7
    Metres Gained: Hindmarsh 62 - 56
    DH Runs: Hindmarsh 1 - 0
    Errors: Hindmarsh 0 - 0.5
    Mistackles: Hindmarsh 1 - 1.8

    Overall:
    Ian Hindmarsh - 8.5
    Kylie Leului - 3.5


    Jason King v Marshall Chalk

    Tries: Tied 0 - 0
    Points: Tied 0 - 0
    Tackles: Chalk 27.7 - 17
    Offloads: Chalk 0.3 - 0
    Kicks: Tied 0 - 0
    Try Assists: Tied 0 - 0
    Line Breaks: Chalk 0.3 - 0
    Hitups: King 9 - 8.3
    Metres Gained: King 73 - 63.3
    DH Runs: Chalk 0.7 - 0
    Errors: King 0 - 1.3
    Mistackles: King 0 - 1.7

    Overall:
    Jason King - 6
    Marshall Chalk - 6


    Canberra - 113.5
    Manly - 90.5
     
  2. Fluffy

    Fluffy Well-Known Member

    17,768
    1,417
    Ratings:
    +3,624 / 132
    yeah but interesntingly if you match up opposite centres, wingers, props and second rowers you get different.

    Eg watmough Vs Adamson

    Watmough = 7.5 (beaver 6.5)

    Beaver Vs Kahler

    Beaver = 7

    So our total in the second row could have been 14.5 instead of 12

    Which alone make the totals 93 vs 111
     
  3. Fluffy

    Fluffy Well-Known Member

    17,768
    1,417
    Ratings:
    +3,624 / 132
    swap wingers -

    donald 5.
    Hicks - 2.5

    Total 7.5 Vs 7

    93.5 Vs 110.5
     
  4. The Wheel

    The Wheel Well-Known Member

    10,890
    805
    Ratings:
    +1,766 / 72
    Does this mean we will be getting flogged?
     
  5. fLIP

    fLIP UFO Hunter

    6,779
    351
    Brisbane
    Ratings:
    +790 / 15
    You can't stuff with the books fluffy to make us look good. Its comparrison with the players exact oposite.
     
  6. Fluffy

    Fluffy Well-Known Member

    17,768
    1,417
    Ratings:
    +3,624 / 132
    props

    heacks 7
    Kite 7.5

    Total 14.5 Vs 12.5

    95.5 VS 108.5

    Much closer now.
     
  7. byso

    byso Well-Known Member

    9,609
    83
    Ratings:
    +83 / 0
    Well done Flipper......some good stats.

    I think the points one isn't required the goalkicker would always win that stat.
    <span class='smallblacktext'>[ Edited Fri Apr 15 2005, 12:45PM ]</span>
     
  8. Fluffy

    Fluffy Well-Known Member

    17,768
    1,417
    Ratings:
    +3,624 / 132
    Exact opposite??

    Do Hecks and Kite always stand one to each side??

    And think about this - the player playing opposite to you is not on the same side of the field - ie left plays on right. Hence the left side is easier to pass to for right handers naturally so should get more ball.

    So match left Vs left or player Vs player - they are both legit reasons.
     
  9. fLIP

    fLIP UFO Hunter

    6,779
    351
    Brisbane
    Ratings:
    +790 / 15
    I thought about that byso. I choose to go with a player who can slot a field goal or has goal kicking ability realy does have the better all round game than one who doesnt so they deserve the point.

    Its just stats though guys, lets not get to serious with them.
     
  10. fLIP

    fLIP UFO Hunter

    6,779
    351
    Brisbane
    Ratings:
    +790 / 15
    Fluffy, when talking your opposite on a football field, it is refering to position, not who is standing dirrectly opposite you.

    Thats dancing.......
     
  11. Fluffy

    Fluffy Well-Known Member

    17,768
    1,417
    Ratings:
    +3,624 / 132
    But thats who you are matching up against - if your left winger it doenst worry you who is playing on the opposite wing, its the person you are playing against.

    Have it your way - our wingers and centres stay but its hardly messing with the books in the forwards
     
  12. willstyles

    willstyles Active Member

    1,644
    4
    Ratings:
    +4 / 0
    Whoah, our backs dominate the Raiders in terms of missed tackles. Cool.
     

Share This Page